← All guides

Rufus vs Ventoy vs balenaEtcher vs Media Creation Tool

Last updated:

All four tools make bootable USB drives, but they are built for different jobs. Rufus gives the most control over a single image, Ventoy holds many images on one drive, balenaEtcher is the simplest and runs on every system, and Microsoft's Media Creation Tool only makes standard Windows installers.

At a glance

ToolRuns onBest forSeveral ISOs on one driveWindows 11 setup options
RufusWindowsWindows installers, Linux live drives, DOS drivesNoYes
VentoyWindows, LinuxCarrying many ISOs on one driveYesLimited
balenaEtcherWindows, macOS, LinuxLinux and Raspberry Pi imagesNoNo
Media Creation ToolWindowsA standard Windows 10 or 11 installerNoNo

When Rufus is the right choice

  • You are making a Windows 11 installer and want to remove the TPM 2.0, Secure Boot or Microsoft-account requirements, or create a local account in advance.
  • You need a specific layout: GPT or MBR, UEFI or legacy BIOS, FAT32 or NTFS.
  • You want a Linux live drive that keeps files and settings between boots (a persistent partition).
  • You need a FreeDOS drive for a BIOS or firmware update.
  • You want a small program that runs without installation: Rufus is a single file of about 2 MB.

When Ventoy is better

Ventoy is installed on the drive once. After that you copy ISO files onto it like ordinary files, and a menu at boot lets you pick one. That makes it the better tool for a technician's drive holding several Windows and Linux images. The trade-offs are that a few ISOs do not boot through Ventoy, and Secure Boot needs a one-time key enrolment on each PC.

When balenaEtcher is better

balenaEtcher has three steps and almost no settings, and it runs on macOS and Linux as well as Windows, so it is the usual choice on a Mac. It writes images exactly as they are, which suits Linux and Raspberry Pi images but not Windows ISOs: Etcher itself warns that a Windows image needs special handling. It is also a much larger download than Rufus.

When the Media Creation Tool is better

Microsoft's tool downloads the current Windows release and writes it to a USB drive in one go. Use it when you want a standard, unmodified Windows installer and nothing else. It cannot use an ISO you already have, offers no setup options, and makes Windows drives only.

Can I use more than one?

Yes. They do not conflict, and many people keep a Ventoy drive for everyday repairs and use Rufus when a Windows installer needs particular options. All four are free. Rufus and Ventoy are released under the GPLv3 license, and balenaEtcher under Apache 2.0.

Download Rufus 4.16 →

← All guides